May 12, 2008
Murray (The Beliefnet Guide to Evangelical Christianity
) lowered herself into ancient ruins, chatted with nuns behind iron grilles and pored over documents in four languages to research and write this story of Francis of Assisi, the medieval saint whose appeal is timeless. In a work that is both scholarly and engaging, Murray retells the life of this “complicated man”—who was poet, warrior, knight, lover, madman and saint—in a way that even those familiar with Francis's story will find compelling. Of special interest is the way she handles the relationship between Francis and Clare of Assisi. Acknowledging what scholars and historians have tended to dismiss as “sentimental, modern and implausible,” Murray holds that the pair's attachment was rooted in love, but that it evolved into a mutual renunciation and remained pure as they took religious vows. She also shows that the age difference between Francis and Clare may not have been great enough to support the official Catholic position that their bond was merely that of father and daughter.
October 15, 2008
Murray, a former senior writer for "Christianity Today" and author of many Christianity-related books (most as Wendy Murray Zoba), here turns to the well-trodden ground of Saint Francis of Assisi and his relationship with Saint Clare Favorone of Assisi. Most recently, this relationship was the subject of Jon M. Sweeney's "Light in the Dark Ages: The Friendship of Francis and Clare of Assisi". Murray's twist is that, unlike Sweeney or St. Francis's most famous biographer, G.K. Chesterton, and the overwhelming consensus of scholarly historical opinion, she views Francis and Clare's relationship as originating in love. While some readers may find her resultant prosaic reading of the life and writings of St. Francis through this lens fresh and inspiring, others will conclude that her argument, at best, shows that this notion may be just "plausible and]warrants honest exploration." Most libraries will regard this title as optional.Darby Orcutt, North Carolina State Univ. Libs., Raleigh
Copyright 2008 Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.